What Questions Should You Ask Before Hiring Process Development Services?
Omar had three quotes on his desk. One was cheap and short. One was expensive and long. One was somewhere in between and full of jargon. He wanted process development services for a new sensor and had no idea how to compare them. His friend said, “Just ask better questions.” Easy to say, harder to do.
So here’s a practical list, built from what a careful buyer would want and what InchFab’s pages actually show. It won’t make the decision for you, but it will make the conversation sharper and the quotes easier to compare. Keep a pen handy, because some of these are the kind you’ll want to write down.
Why Do Quotes Look so Different?
Because they assume different things. One might include three test loops, mems foundry another only one. One may cover measurement, another may not. One could assume your design is final, another expects changes. Without matching assumptions, you’re comparing apples to bicycles.
The cure is to ask each provider the same set of questions in the same order. Then put the answers side by side. Omar made a simple grid, with providers across the top and questions down the side. His cheap quote suddenly looked a lot less cheap.
What Do the Pages Tell You up Front?
On InchFab’s side, the pages state a few things clearly: custom processes built from scratch or adapted, early development turnaround as fast as one week, cost per chip comparable to traditional 200mm to 300mm foundries in volume, and a modular platform that can grow. They also list unit processes and facility specs.
They don’t list prices, terms or intellectual property rules. Those are fair questions for the team. I wouldn’t treat the missing details as a negative, just as a reminder that web pages rarely hold the whole story and a call usually fills the gaps.
Which Questions Matter Most?
Start with scope. What exactly will you do for me? Which steps, which tools, which measurements? How many experiment loops does the quote cover? If the answer is fuzzy, push for a written list. Fuzzy scope grows into expensive surprises.
Then ask about people. Who will work on my project, and how often will we talk? Who reviews the data? A strong team gives names and a rhythm. A weak one says “our engineers” and changes the subject. Omar noticed which providers answered quickly and which didn’t, and that mattered.
What About Risk?
Ask what happens if a step fails. Who pays for lost wafers? Does the schedule slip, and by how much? What’s the plan if the first recipe doesn’t work? These aren’t pessimistic questions, they’re normal ones, and honest providers have clear answers.
Also ask what the team thinks is the riskiest part of your device. A good reply is specific, like a deep etch or a bonded seal. A vague one suggests they haven’t thought about it. The InchFab Line lists DRIE and aligned bonding, both common risk points, so it’s a useful starting topic.
How Should You Compare Capability?
Look at the tools. The InchFab Line page lists maskless lithography, coating, DRIE, RIE oxide and nitride, HDPCVD, sputter, e beam evaporation, a 4 tank plating tool, acid and solvent stations, a furnace stack, drying and bonding. Check whether your flow fits that toolbox, and whether another provider’s list fits better.
The Foundry Service page also lists unit processes such as RIE, Bosch DRIE, HDPCVD, PECVD, metal liftoff, metal deposition, oxidation, lithography, plating, wet etch and ALD, with others on request. When comparing process development services, line up each step of your flow against each provider’s list and note the gaps.
What About Wafer Size and Fit?
InchFab’s line uses 100mm wafers. If your design is built for something larger, say so early. Fit matters as much as capability. A great provider with the wrong wafer size is the wrong provider, no matter how nice the sales call felt.
Also ask about your device type. The Foundry Service page lists markets from MEMS and sensors to photonics, RF, power, packaging and research. If yours is on the list, good. If not, ask anyway, since lists never cover everything and custom work is the whole point.
How Do You Check Growth and Continuity?
Ask what happens after development. Can the same team and platform handle repeated runs? The Foundry Service page says it supports customers from early development to volume production, and the InchFab Line page describes modular lines for different lifecycle stages. Ask how that works in practice.
Also ask about documentation. After development, you should have a written process you can reuse. If it lives only in someone’s head, you’re in trouble when they leave. Omar added a line to his grid: “Who owns the written recipe?” Two providers hesitated, which told him plenty.
Who Owns What?
Ask about intellectual property and confidentiality in plain words. Who owns the process, the layout and the data? Can you move the process elsewhere later? The pages I read don’t state a policy, so get it in writing from any provider before you share sensitive designs.
Use the contact page or . A clear, direct answer is a good sign, and a slippery one is worth noting. Omar sent the question to all three and compared replies. The best provider answered within a day, in plain language, with no drama.
What Else Should You Keep in Mind?
Trust your sense of the conversation. Do they listen? Do they ask about your device? Do they explain things without talking down to you? Process development is a long collaboration, and working well together matters almost as much as technical skill.
Also keep your expectations sensible. Nobody can promise a perfect process on the first try. The InchFab homepage includes comments from MEMS pioneers Kurt Petersen and Charles Yang, which are encouraging, but your own project needs its own evidence. Ask for it.
So, What Did Omar Choose?
He picked the middle quote, not because it was cheapest, but because the team answered every question clearly and proposed a first test he hadn’t thought of. He’s not sure the process will work, and he doesn’t need to be. He needs a partner who’ll find out honestly.
If you’re about to choose, build your own grid, ask the same questions to everyone and compare the answers calmly. Whatever you pick, write down the assumptions. It’s the simplest way to keep your project on track and your temper intact.
FAQs
What should I ask about scope?
Which steps, tools and measurements are included, and how many experiment loops the quote covers.
Does InchFab publish prices?
Not on the pages I read. Use the contact page or .
Which wafer size does the line use?
The InchFab Line page lists 100mm, or 4 inch, wafers.
Does InchFab state an IP policy?
Not on the pages I read, so ask directly and get the answer in writing.
0 comments
Log in to leave a comment.
Be the first to comment.