NCDRC Advocate: Legal Representation for Consumer Complaints and Appeals in India ?
Problems with goods or services supplied may lead to considerable loss and distress. It is desirable to be represented by an advocate if large amounts of money are involved or if it becomes necessary to approach the NCDRC Advocate to appeal against a decision.
A knowledgeable advocate will be able to advise on one's entitlement, the merits of the case, draft necessary pleadings and appear on one's behalf before the NCDRC.
This could relate to non-delivery or delay in possession of immovable property, insurance, deficiency in services by banks and other institutions, manufactures and suppliers of goods, and many other areas. An advocate well-versed in this field would be able to advise what relief may be available.
What Is an NCDRC Advocate?
An NCDRC Advocate would appear on behalf of consumers, traders, companies and others who are entitled to approach this forum.
It is the apex forum for deciding consumer complaints. It has jurisdiction to try original complaints as also appeals and revisions against orders of the State Commissions.
Some of the matters in which one may require the services of an NCDRC advocate are:
Filing of original complaint, subject to the minimum value of the transaction;
Appeal against the order of a State Consumer Commission;
Revision, subject to fulfilment of the prescribed conditions;
Disputes of buyers from builders;
Disputes relating to non-payment or inadequate payment of insurance policies;
Grievances against banks and other financial institutions;
Defect in goods and deficiency in services;
Seeking interim orders;
Execution of various orders.
Naturally, it would be desirable that the case is duly substantiated with all material on record and argued to establish a strong legal proposition.
Why Should You Hire an Experienced NCDRC Advocate?
1. To determine if the matter is maintainable
There will be various questions of law and fact in each case, for example, whether there is a deficiency, defective product or unfair trade practice. It is desirable that an advocate look into all aspects and advise if there is a violation of any of the provisions of the Act.
This would also indicate what reliefs the consumer can claim.
2. To correctly draft various pleadings and documents
A large number of pleadings and documents will usually be required in any case before the consumer commissions.
A Lawyer for NCDRC will be able to draft a variety of documents including the complaint, appeal, affidavit, various applications and written arguments, in addition to advising as to other documents required to substantiate the plea.
This will bring out all material points in dispute between the parties, avoiding unnecessary defects.
3. To argue the case
Issues on construction of statute, terms of contract, period of limitation, weighing and appreciating evidence, and others may come up.
The advocate would be able to submit submissions on behalf of the consumer, citing provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 and other rules as well as decisions of law.
4. To file appeal and revision
As mentioned earlier, a person aggrieved by an order of the State Commission may, in certain circumstances, appeal to the NCDRC.
It is however, necessary to ascertain whether an appeal lies or if a revision is the appropriate remedy, which will again be dependent on several factors.
It is advisable to seek the opinion of a lawyer on this.
5. Claim suitable relief
The various consumer commissions can direct the opposite party to make a refund, pay monetary compensation, remove the deficiency, provide other appropriate relief and pay costs.
An advocate specializing in consumer compensation would be able to advise and adduce appropriate evidence to establish these reliefs.
Common Consumer Disputes Handled by NCDRC Advocates
Disputes relating to Builders and Home-buyers
This is another significant head under which a large number of consumer complaints are filed.
These may be about late possession, defects, breach of various terms of agreement, non-provision of amenities, and so on.
In all such cases, the Advocate would want to see the agreement entered into with the builder, various cheques paid, date of promised and actual possession, letters exchanged and promises and allures held out.
Reliefs can range from refund of amounts paid with interest to award of damages, as considered fit and proper in each case.
Thus, if a considerable amount has been paid towards purchase of flat or flats and the buyer has not been able to take possession on the due date, he may wish to file a complaint, if otherwise maintainable.
Non-payment or dispute as to quantum of insurance payable
Denial of a valid insurance claim, delay in paying, making unjustified deductions and disputes on various clauses of the policy are some of the common problems faced.
The Advocate would want to scrutinise all terms of the policy, letters exchanged in connection with the claim, the surveyor's report, relevant documents (such as medical or valuation records) and grounds relied on by the Insurance Company to reject the claim.
Obviously it would be necessary to establish how and why this amounts to deficiency in service or any other contravention.
Various Banking and allied services
It is self-evident that a wide range of services are extended by banks, and many of these can attract consumer action, as and when warranted.
For instance, unauthorised debit from the account, deficiency in service, levy of undue amounts, ignoring justified grievances and so on.
NCDRC Appeal Lawyer: Challenging State Consumer Commission Orders
An NCDRC Appeal Lawyer would be approached to file an appeal against any order, appealable in law, passed by a State Commission.
Obviously, it would not suffice to merely be dissatisfied with such order. It would be necessary to show one or more errors in the findings recorded, the law applied or the evidence on record.
Some examples would be:
Wrong principles of law applied;
Ignoring documents on record which were material to the dispute;
Various errors leading to erroneous conclusions as to deficiency of service;
Erroneous view taken regarding terms of contract and the obligations of the parties;
Award of compensation not sustainable in law.
Appeals to the NCDRC would ordinarily have to be preferred within 30 days of such order, in accordance with provisions as to condonation and admissibility of delayed appeals. A pre-deposit may be called for in some cases.
National Consumer Helpline - NCH+1
It is thus desirable that the impugned order be scrutinised within a reasonable time from its date.
NCDRC Revision Petition: When Is It Appropriate?
A petition for revision is distinct from an appeal.
It lies in the supervisory jurisdiction of the higher Court to correct certain jurisdictional errors and material irregularities. It would not amount to a free license to review all questions of fact and law de novo.
Therefore, a petition for revision would lie if the subordinate Consumer Commission has assumed and exercised a jurisdiction not conferred on it, refused to exercise a jurisdiction properly vested in it or committed some jurisdictional error or material irregularity while exercising its jurisdiction.
As provided under the relevant Consumer Commission Regulations, such a petition can ordinarily be filed within 90 days from the date of receipt of a certified copy of the impugned order, as allowed by law.
IndiaCode
It will be advisable to take up the matter with a good National Consumer Commission advocate, who will be able to advise if there is scope for filing a revision and if it would be worthwhile.
Online NCDRC Complaint Filing and Digital Consumer Justice
Consumers can make use of various facilities available to them electronically.
With effect from 1 January 2025, all existing applications relating to administration of consumer justice such as e-Daakhil, are available on a single window, e-Jagriti.
Various other facilities relating to proceedings may also be availed of electronically.
Source: PIB
While consumers may thus avoid having to personally appear before the forum for some of these purposes, all other conditions such as jurisdiction, limitation, production of documents and scrutiny will continue to apply as usual.
Appropriate documentation for this purpose can be drafted with the assistance of an advocate practising before the NCDRC.
How Long Does an NCDRC Consumer Case Take?
It will vary with, for example, the nature and difficulty of the issues to be determined, the amount of evidence, any interlocutory applications, the convenience of those involved and current workloads.
Clearly one aim of the Act is speedy determination of complaints. Subject to various provisions, complaints would normally be expected to be determined within about 3 months of service on the other side of an notice of appearance, or 5 months if tests and analyses are called for.
Of course these are only targets set by the legislation.
Press Information Bureau
Appropriate advice should be given to consumers as to likely lengths of time, the number of days required for hearings, costs, and the likelihood of compromise.
Common Mistakes Consumers Should Avoid in NCDRC Matters
A consumer matter which otherwise may have good chances of success can be jeopardised if one does not comply with certain basic requirements.
These may range from approaching an inappropriate forum; failure to appreciate the monetary jurisdiction based on consideration; delay in filing appeals; proceeding on the basis of incomplete record, and seeking relief of damages without properly establishing the same.
It would be wrong to regard a petition for revision before the NCDRC as a full-fledged second appeal.
Further, great care needs to be taken to see whether a particular case is truly 'in relation to' a supply of goods or services for consideration, or whether it has some other commercial end.
It is therefore desirable to seek an opinion at an early stage.
How Can an NCDRC Advocate Help With Consumer Compensation Claims?
Money plays a significant role in most cases.
Naturally, this will depend upon the facts and other merits of the case.
Such losses can include amounts payable under a contract, the degree of deficiency and proof of consequential damages, including mental torture.
Depending upon the circumstances, the Consumer Commission may order a refund of the price paid, replacement and rectification, or any other relief as permitted under law.
There are several types of relief available to consumers under the Act, all subject to the facts and merits of the individual case.
National Consumer Helpline - NCH
Obviously it would be desirable if an advocate could substantiate the amount sought as way of relief.
How to Choose the Right NCDRC Advocate in India
Due regard should naturally be paid to the ability and expertise of the lawyer.
It would be desirable that he is conversant with various aspects of consumer laws, preparation and filing of petitions and appeals, production and proving of documents, and the practice and procedure of the National Commission.
He should explain the fee charges, documents to be furnished, chances of adverse order, and the distinction between what may and what may definitely be expected.
Naturally no one can assure a favourable outcome, which will largely depend upon proper and diligent briefing of the matter and merits under the relevant law.
Frequently Asked Questions?
1. What does an NCDRC Advocate do?
He or she appears on behalf of any party in a complaint, first appeal, revision and other allied matters, if the matter is maintainable before the National Commission.
2. Would a complaint lie directly before the National Commission?
If the conditions regarding its pecuniary and other jurisdiction are met, then yes. Currently, as per the rules of 2021, consideration should be more than Rs. 2 crores, fulfilling other conditions.
3. Would he appear in a matter relating to builders?
If the home buyer is entitled to do so under the law, he would appear in cases relating to non or late delivery of possession, poor quality of work and materials used, breach of agreement or contract and seek refund, damages, compensation and such other relief.
4. How long does a consumer have to approach a forum?
Ordinarily a period of 2 years is provided from the date when the cause of action occurred. This can be excused for good and sufficient reasons as permitted under the Act.
5. Can I appeal to the NCDRC if a decision has been made by a State Commission?
Subject to conditions and limitations, a party can prefer an appeal before the National Commission against orders passed by State Commissions. The limitation for the same would ordinarily be 30 days.
6. Would an NCDRC advocate appear in insurance related disputes?
He could represent a party who seeks redressal in case of non-payment or delayed payment of insurance proceeds, deficient services, unjustified deduction etc., subject to the conditions to approach a consumer forum being fulfilled.
7. Can I file my complaint online?
Yes, through the website e-Jagriti. Of course, the complaint would be required to fulfill all the usual conditions to be filed before a Consumer Forum.
8. If an order has been passed, can he assist to get it executed?
If warranted and depending upon the nature of order, he could take suitable steps before the appropriate authority.
9. Is it essential to appoint an Advocate?
There is no such requirement and the consumer himself can prosecute his matter. However, if there are large amounts involved and a number of issues and documents to be placed before the Forum, especially on appeal, it may be prudent to seek assistance.
10. Is a further appeal provided to the Supreme Court?
Depending upon the nature of the impugned order, a party may approach the Supreme Court, within the prescribed time and subject to other conditions.
Conclusion:
Consumer legislation offers a variety of relief for deficient services, defective products and unfair trade practices. Of course, to effectively argue such matters before the Forum it is necessary to be aware of various aspects, including jurisdiction, period of limitation, formal and other requirements and documentation.
A lawyer practising before the NCDRC would be able to advise on the merits, draft a complaint and or appeal and avail of various other reliefs open to the consumer.
NCDRC Lawyers can be approached by any person or firm for advice and representation in a wide range of consumer problems. This includes complaints and appeals before the NCDRC, disputes between builders and purchasers, insurance claims and other allied areas. Any person can approach them to ascertain what relief, if any, may be open to him.
0 comments
Log in to leave a comment.
Be the first to comment.